Chris Wickham’s acclaimed history shows how this period, encompassing peoples such as Goths, Franks, Vandals, Byzantines, Arabs. Review: The Inheritance of Rome: A History of Europe from to by Chris WickhamIan Mortimer finds a gallop from Rome to the. The Inheritance of Rome has ratings and reviews. Justin said: Just to be clear: Chris Wickham does not believe that he can explain anything. He.
|Published (Last):||11 June 2005|
|PDF File Size:||8.34 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||17.95 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
Illuminating the Dark Ages” is a very inheritanc and witty survey of Late Antiquity and the early Middle Ages that shatters many kinds of misconceptions on the period, even if I think it’s at some points overrated. The Islamic world is treated a bit worse as Wickham just relies too much on later 9th century accounts which form the traditional narrative of the period, which has been challenged in the last decades by “Orientalists”, so its value is a bit reduced, although it’s decent as an introduction.
In the eastern Mediterranean, in any case, Roman rule continued for centuries. Wickham brings both a sense of humor and a lively flair for storytelling to his history of the era, touching on Christian hermits as the Roman equivalent of “Dear Abby” and what I Inheritance of Rome discusses Late Antiquity and the early Middle Ages, beginning with the “fall” of the Roman Inheritnce in the West and transformation into the Byzantine Empire in the East and continuing through the series of political and economic shifts that took place around the beginning of the eleventh century.
There are three reasons for this. The reviews I read of this inherktance were not promising; however, I found it to be readable, interesting, and as comprehensive a survey of this vast stretch of time as could be hoped for. Top Reviews Most recent Top Reviews.
I also loved his emphasis on the study of the peasantry “in opposition” to the inhheritance of all those medieval societies namely the Frankishwhen the book could have easily have become just a history of the elites and the church. Three cheers for that. Wickham too often handwaves between continuity and change, frequently saying they both go too far, but without providing any convincing or integrated model, or even description, that would actually make an intermediate position plausible.
Explore the Home Dome Guide.
The Inheritance of Rome by Chris Wickham – review
For centuries afterwards, no one quite believed that the Roman Empire had actually passed away and much of the history of the Early Middle Ages is the history of trying to restore the Empire, culminating in the great Carolingian project. On the one hand, the era was not nearly as dark as is sometimes supposed. Unlike so many lazy post-September 11, popular histories, this book gives us little sense of a clash of civilisations; instead, Rone shows how inheritnace empires were the heirs of Rome, and how they inherihance strikingly similar economic and ideological dilemmas.
Other editions – View all The Inheritance of Rome: In part II, the early medieval West from to is investigated and unraveled wonderfully before the reader, from the “shadowy” regions of Britain and Ireland to the Lombard and Visigothic kingdoms. So goes the popular understanding of Roman contact with the peoples of Germania.
Like the earlier book, The Inheritance of Rome is more concerned with the uses the people of the era made of their understanding of the past than with giving a straightforward chronology of the era. Wickham’s own view is that all grand narratives are in themselves suspect.
As time went by, those settled barbarian groups became the origins of later medieval kingdoms, but only after becoming far more Roman in culture than barbarian. Not just the big picture stuff eg. Nope, we should see things as they were seen at the time. Viking- History chrie pages. Alexa Actionable Analytics for the Web.
The Inheritance of Rome by Chris Wickham | : Books
The book contains maps at critical dates, a page by page reference at the back contains all sources as well as an index. JustinianSaint ColumbaBede. It is insightful and well written, and a joy to consume. Covering a whopping great years of history, it’s small wonder that this book took two months to read. There’s more information about the Byzantine Empire than many other general surveys of medieval history.
Speeding through the centuries
Apr 02, Gavin rated it it was amazing Shelves: Dec 14, Ian Mapp rated it it was ok Shelves: As a result, one can see more clearly both the Roman and the barbarian influences on the cultures of the so-called Dark Ages. More integration of archaeology into the account might have helped, although I’m not certain.
The second distortion results from the notion that the period was chiefly important for “the birth of nations”. The problem is that there’s rarely a deep dive into a person, experience, or event that in any way captures interest.
Highly recommended as counterpart to both sensationalist account of the “fall of Rome” and the “darkness that came” on one hand, and “what fall, nothing really changed that much” on the other, as well as treating the subject without the benefit of hindsight and what came later, but in its own terms The period covered in this book is often roem to as the Dark Ages.
Chris Wickham does not believe that he can explain anything. In any case given Wickham’s reputation I had expected a more economic historical focus. If you’re looking for information about individuals though, this book is great. Nor is there much about early Germanic religion, other than Aryan and Catholic Christianity. The exceptions are just as historical as the generalisations.
Wickham begins with an overview of the Roman Empire just before its decline, characterizing the Empire at its height and emphasizing that its failure was gradual and almost imperceptible during the lifetimes of its citizens.
The second is – and this may owe as much to the documentary evidence as anything lf that the book is by and large a fairly traditional political narrative history, with social and economic history coming a distant second and all other themes an afterthought. I did continue reading, though, because I didn’t think this kind of willful political obtuseness would have an effect on his accounts on medieval history, but it was enough to make me a little skeptical about some of his views on the medieval European economy.
Artefacts are not discussed in any aesthetic sense but only in regard to whether their physical distribution is evidence of commercial networks or royal gift-giving. I like the way the book is broken up into parts.
In recent decades historians have moved to viewing this date as not that fome and stressing the continuation of the Roman world as the political apparatus changed. In contrast, the imperial tax system collected money from the peasantry after they had sold their produce in local markets.
ComiXology Thousands of Digital Comics. It’s actually kind of mind-numbing that someone could gather it and filter it into a massive work like this.